ICC Legal Tools: Researching international criminal law

May 29th, 2009 • 1 comment Law, Resources, UN
Tags: icc, jurisprudence, Law, research, search engine

When it comes to international criminal law jurisprudence, there hasn’t really been an easy starting point for legal research. Each of the Tribunals have their own websites where they list decisions, but these are often difficult to search and the links themselves can also be unreliable.

For my own use, I created an ICL search engine that used Google to search all of the different Tribunals at once – but this would only be effective while the sites kept their current structure.

Thankfully, the ICC this week re-launched their Legal Tools website, providing a new and better place to do ICL research.

Legal Tools is a comprehensive resource of international criminal case law, and relevant international and domestic material. It contains judgments from all the major international Tribunals, going back to Nuremberg and Tokyo; relevant international legal instruments and decisions; and relevant legislation and cases from domestic jurisdictions. Also, it doesn’t require registration, you just agree with the terms and conditions and you have full access to either search or browse the database.

Of course it isn’t perfect. At times it feels a bit clunky, it certainly isn’t at a Google-level of sophistication. The results are often limited by the format of the source database – which can sometimes mean non-text PDFs. And some sources can’t be clicked through to due to copyrights issues.

But it does look like it will be a fantastic resource. The advanced search particularly looks to be a very powerful tool for specific searches of international criminal law. It’d be nice if the results were more friendly to Google, so that you could run a typical Google search over the database – but hopefully that’s something for the future, this could be a great addition to Google Scholar.

Transparency and accessibility of the law is crucial to the legitimacy and efficiency of the Tribunals. Access is currently at an barely usable level, and things definitely could be better. The ICC Legal Tools is a significant step in the right direction and it’ll be interesting to see where things go from here. We’ve seen increasing demands for domestic transparency in governments, let’s hope this also is reflected on the international level soon.

Popularity: 5% [?]